Технічна діагностика та неруйнівний контроль, 2014, №04



2014 №04 (07)

2014 №04 (02)

---

Техническая диагностика и неразрушающий контроль, №4, 2014 стр. 3-11
 

Застосування методу акустичної емісії для діагностування корпусів ядерних реакторів (огляд). Повідомлення ІІ. Метод акустичної емісії в діагностуванні корпусів реакторів АЕС. Частина 1

І. М. Неклюдов, З. Т. Назарчук, В. Р. Скальський, Л. Н. Добровольська

 
Реферат:
Перші акустико-емісійні (АЕ) вимірювальні системи виробничого зразка та встановлені кореляції між параметрами сигналів АЕ та показниками розвитку руйнування були створені у другій половині XX сторіччя. Саме це й стало підставою зацікавлення розробників атомних енергетичних технологій та експлуатаційників цим новим методом, який згодом стане ефективним доповненням до існуючих технологій неруйнівного контролю (НК) для виявлення та моніторингу дефектів корпусів ядерних реакторів. Оскільки до таких об’єктів поставлено винятково високі вимоги якості та цілісності, то вже в кінці 1970-х років було спрямовано значні зусилля на розвиток методу АЕ і запровадження його у виробництво. Практична реалізація засобів і методик АЕ-моніторингу та діагностування стану корпусів реакторів АЕС підтвердила високу ефективність методу, хоча на початках їх становлення були різні твердження щодо цього.
 
Ключові слова: акустична емісія, показники розвитку руйнування, атомні енергетичні технології, виявлення та моніторинг дефектів
 
1. Prognostics and health management in nuclear power plants: a review of technologies and applications / J. B. Coble, P. Ramuhalli, L. J. Bond et al. / Report PNNL–21515. – Richland: Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, July 2012. – 124 p.
2. Dunegan H. L., Harris D. O., Tatro C. A. Fracture analysis by use of acoustic emission // Engineering Fracture Mechanics. – 1968. – 1. – P. 105–122.
3. Dunegan H., Harris D. Acoustic emission – a new nondestructive testing tool // Ultrasonics. –1969. – 7. – P. 160–166.
4. Harris D. O., Tetelman A. S., Darwish F. A. Detection of fiber cracking by acoustic emission // Acoustic Emission, ASTM STP 505. – Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1972. – P. 238–249.
5. Bently P. G. A review of acoustic emission for pressurised water reactor applications // NDT International. – 1981. – 14. – P. 329–335.
6. Liptai R. G., Tatro C. A. Acoustic emission technique in nondestructive testing / preprint № UCRL-74549: submitted to the Proc. of the 7th Intern. conf. on Nondestructive Testing; Warsaw, May 28 – June 1, 1973. – Lawrence Livermore Laboratory of the University of California, 1973. – 10 p.
7. Acoustic emission test on a 25 mm thick mild steel pressure vessel with inserted defects / P. G. Bentley, D. G. Dawson, D. J. Hanley, N. Kirby // Proс. of the 3rd сonf. on Periodic inspection of pressurized components, London, Sept. 20–22, 1976. – London: The Institution of Mechanical Engineers, 1976. – P. 113–124.
8. Watanabe T., Hashirizaki S., Arita H. A method of evaluating the harmfulness of flaws in structures using AE techniques // Proc. of the 4-th Acoustic Emission Symposium, Tokyo, Japan, Sept. 18–20, 1978. – Tokyo, 1978. – P. 5.59–5.69.
9. Watanabe T. Inspection of large pressure vessels by acoustic emission technique // Welding and Metal Fabrication. – 1975. – 43. – P. 525–527.
10. Watanabe T., Hashirizaki S., Arita H. Acoustic-emission inspection during water-pressure testing of pressure vessels // NDT International. – 1976. – 9. – P. 227–232.
11. Hutton P. H. Detecting acoustic emission in the presence of hydraulic noise // Non-Destructive Testing. – 1969. – 2. – P. 111–115.
12. Hutton P. H. Acoustic emission in metals as an NDT tool // Materials Evaluation. – 1968. – 26, № 7. – P. 125–129.
13. Hutton P. H. Acoustic emission applied outside of the laboratory // Acoustic Emission, ASTM STP 505. – Philadelphia: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1972. – P. 114–128.
14. Green A. T. Detection of incipient failures in pressure vessels by stress-wave emissions // Nuclear Safety. – 1969. – 10, №1. – Р. 4–18.
15. Use of acoustic emission for the detection of weld and stress corrosion cracking / C. E. Hartbower, W. G. Reuter, C. F. Morais, P. P. Crimmins // Acoustic Emission, ASTM STP505. – Philadelphia: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1972. – P. 187–221.
16. Harris D. O., Dunegan H. L. Acoustic emission – 5. Application of acoustic emission to industrial problems // Non-Destructive Testing. – 1974. – 7. – P. 137–144.
17. Engle R. B., Dunegan H. Acoustic emission: stress wave detection as a tool for nondestructive testing and material evaluation, Lawrence Livermore Laboratory Rept. № UCRL-71267 [submitted to 8th Symposium on Physics and Nondestructive Testing, Schiller Park, IL, Sept. 24–26, 1968]. – 28 p.
18. Dunegan H. L., Harris D. O., Tetelman A. S. Detection of fatigue crack growth by acoustic emission techniques // Materials Evaluation. – 1970. – 28, № 10. – P. 221–227.
19. Harris D. O., Dunegan H. L. Continuous monitoring of fatigue crack growth by acoustic emission techniques // Experimental Mechanics. – 1974. – 11. – P. 71–81.
20. Ying S. P., Hamlin D. R., Whiting A. R. Acoustic emission from welds, ceramic materials, and radiation effect of the emission from nuclear reactor steel // Proc. of the 9th Symposium on Non-destructive evaluation; Apr. 25–27, 1973, San Antonio, TX. – San Antonio, TX: ASNT and SWRI, 1973. – P. 217–223.
21. Ying S. P. Characteristics and mechanisms of acoustic emission from solids under applied stress // Critical Reviews in Solid State Science. – 1973. – 4. – P. 85–123.
22. Ying S. P., Grigory S. C. Acoustic emission from flawed heavy section steel plates // Materials Evaluation. – 1975. – 33. – P. 30–36.
23. Ying S. P. Effect of crack size on acoustic emission related to moving dislocations // J. of Applied Physics. – 1975. – 46, № 2882. – 7 p.
24. Ying S. P. The use of acoustic emission for assessing the integrity of a nuclear reactor pressure vessel // NDT International. – 1979. – 12. – P. 175–179.
25. Palmer I. G. The application of acoustic emission measurements to fracture mechanics // Materials Sci. and Engin. – 1973. – 11. – P. 181–184.
26. Palmer I. G. Acoustic emission measurements on reactor pressure vessel steel // Ibid. – 1973. – 11. – P. 227–236.
27. Palmer I. G. The relationship between acoustic emission and crack opening displacement measurements // Ibid. – 1974. – 14. – P. 3–6.
28. Lindley T. C., Palmer I. G., Richards C. E. Acoustic emission monitoring of fatigue crack growth // Ibid. – 1978. – 32. – P. 1–15.
29. Parry D. L. Nondestructive flaw detection by use of acoustic emissions // Technical Report IDO–17230, Atomic Energy Division of Phillips Petroleum Co., Idaho Falls, 1967. – 44 p.
30. Parry D. L. Incipient failure detection by acoustic emissions: A development and status report // Techn. Report № IN–1398. – Idaho Falls: Idaho Nuclear Corp, 1970. – 111 p.
31. Parry D. L. Nondestructive flaw detection in nuclear power installations // Transactions of the American Nuclear Sociaty. – 1967. – 10. – P. 107–126.
32. Parry D. L., Robinson D. L. Incipient failure detection by acoustic emission. A development and status report. – Idaho Falls: Idaho Nuclear Corp., 1970. – 102 p.
33. Waite E. V., Parry D. L. Field evaluation of heavy-walled pressure vessels using acoustic emission analysis // Materials Evaluation. – 1971. – 29, № 6. – P. 117–124.
34. Pollock A. A. Stress-wave emission in ndt // Non-Destructive Testing. – 1969 – 2. – P. 178–182.
35. Pollock. A. A. Stress-wave emission – a new tool for industry // Ultrasonics. – 1968. – 6, № 2. – Р. 88–92.
36. Sinclair A. C., Connors D. C., Formby E. C. L. Acoustic emission analysis during fatigue crack growth in steel // Materials Sci. and Engin. – 1977. – 28. – P. 263–273.
37. Sinclair A. C. E., Formby C. L., Connors D. C. Acoustic emission from a defective C/Mn steel pressure vessel // Intern. Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping. – 1975. – 3, № 3 – P. 153–174.
38. Fujimura T., Kamata Y., Nakanii T. Applicability of AE method to nuclear reactor vessel // Proc. of the Japan–U.S. joint symposium on Acoustic emission and its applications to structural safety; July 4–6, 1972, Tokyo / High Pressure Institute of Japan and Japan Society for Non Destructive Inspection. – Tokyo: Japan Industrial Planning Association, 1972. – P. 90–104.
39. Gopal R. On-line acoustic emission monitoring systems for nuclear power plants // Proc. of the Japan–U.S. joint symposium on Acoustic emission and its applications to structural safety; July 4–6, 1972, Tokyo / High Pressure Institute of Japan and Japan Society for Non Destructive Inspection. – Tokyo: Japan Industrial Planning Association, 1972. – P. 273–274.
40. Report on the integrity of reactor vessels for light water power reactors. The Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards // Nuclear Engineering and Design. – 1974. – 28. – P. 147–195.
41. Drouillard T. E. Acoustic emission – the first half century // Proc. of the 12th Intern. Acoustic emission symposium “Progress in Acoustic Emission”, Sapporo / The Japanese Society for NDE. – 1974, VII. – P. 27–38.
42. Frederick J. R. Acoustic emission as a technique for nondestructive testing // Materials Evaluation. – 1970. – 28, № 2. – P. 43–47.
43. Jolly W. D. The application of acoustic emission to in-process inspection of welds // Ibid. – 1970. – 28, № 6. – P. 135–139.
44. Vetrano J. B., Jolly W. D. In service acoustic emission monitoring of reactor pressure vessels // Ibid. – 1972. – 30, № 1. – P. 9–12.
45. Nichols R. W., Cowan A. The prevention of fracture initiation in reactor structural material // Nuclear Engineering and Design. – 1972. – 20. – P. 287–302.
46. Kelly M. P., Bell R. L. Detection and location of flaw growth in the EBOR nuclear reactor vessels // Report № DE 73–4. – Dunegan Corp, 1973. – 16 p.
47. Bell R. L., Kelly M. P., Dunegan H. L. Acoustic emission monitoring of proof tests simulated in-service nuclear pressure // Transactions of the American Nuclear Society. – 1973. – 16. – P. 85–86.
48. Romrell D. M. Acoustic emission weld monitoring of nuclear components // Weld Journal. – 1973. – 52, № 2. – P. 81–87.
49. Chretien N., Bernard P., Barrachin B. Inspection of steel pressure vessels by acoustic emission // Proc. of the 2nd Intern. сonf. on Pressure vesssel technology, 1–4 Oct. 1973, San Antonio, TX. – New York: American Soc. Mech. Eng, 1973. – P. 655–667.
50. Bell R. L. A progress report on the use of acoustic emission to detect incipient failure in nuclear pressure vessels // Nuclear Safety. – 1974. – 15. – P. 554–571.
51. Bentley P. G., Dawson D. J., Parker J. A. Instrumentation for acoustiuc emission testing of steel pressure vessels // Proc. of the 2nd Acoustic emission symposium, Tokyo, September 2–4, 1974. – Tokyo: Japan Industrial Planning Association, 1974. – P. 3-1–3-29.
52. Ingham T., Stott A. L., Cowan A. Acoustic emission characteristics of steels part 1: Acoustic measurements from tensile tests // Intern. Journal of Pressure Vessels and Piping. – 1974. – 2. – P. 31–50.
53. Ingham T., Stott A. L., Cowan A. Acoustic emission characteristics of steels part 2: Acoustic measurements from fracture toughness tests // Ibid. – 1975. – 3. – P. 267–293.
54. Ingham T., Dawson D. G. Application of acoustic emission measurements on laboratory testpieces to large scale pressure vessel monitoring // Transactions of the 3rd Intern. conf. on Structural mechanics in reactor technology – SMiRT-3, 1–5 Sept. 1975 / Ed. by T.A. Jaeger; International Association on Structural Mechanics in Reactor Techologies and British Nuclear Energy Society. – London: North-Holland, 1975. – 3. – 14 p.
55. Graham L. J., Alers G. A. Acoustic emission in the frequency domain // Monitoring structural integrity by acoustic emission / Ed. by J. C. Spanner, J.W. McElroy. – ASTM STP 571. – Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1975. – P. 11–39.
56. Gopal R. Acoustic monitoring systems to assure integrity of nuclear plants / R. Gopal // Monitoring structural integrity by acoustic emission / Ed. by J. C. Spanner, J.W. McElroy. – ASTM STP 571. – Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials, 1975. – P. 200–220.
57. Gopal R., Smith L. R., Rao G. V. Experience in acoustic monitoring of pressurized water reactor // Proc. of the 3rd conf. on Periodic inspection of pressurized components; Sept. 20–22, 1976; London. – London: The Institution of Mechanical Engineers, 1976. – P. 1–12.
58. Preliminary investigations of on-line AE monitoring system for nuclear power plant / N. Uesugi, K. Tatsuno, K. Uchida, T. Miyazawa // Proc. of the 3rd Acoustic emission symposium. – Tokyo: Japan Industrial Planning Association, 1976. – P. 167–181.
59. Hatano H., Ono K. Acoustic emission during fracture-toughness tests of a nuclear pressure vessel steel and its weldments // Proc. of the 3rd Acoustic emission symposium. – Tokyo: Japan Industrial Planning Association, 1976. – P. 475–491.
60. Clark G., Knott J. F. Acoustic emission and ductile crack growth in pressure-vessel steels // Metal Science. – 1977. – 11. – P. 531–536.
61. Crawford A. H. Non-destructive testing of nuclear power reactor components // Non-Destructive Testing. – 1970. – 3. – P. 217–219.
62. Conference reports: Acoustic emission meeting, London, 14 March // Non-Destructive Testing. – 1972 – 5. – P. 177–178.
63. Kelly M. P., Schlamp R. J. Detecting structural degradation by acoustic emission // Proc. of the 25th meeting of the Mechanical Failures Prevention Group, November 3–5, 1976, Gaithersburg / Ed. by T. R. Shives, W. A. Willard. – SP 487. – Gaithersburg: NBS, 1977. – P. 210–238.
64. Ando Y. Research on structural integrity of pressure boundary in light water reactor designs // Nuclear Engineering and Design. – 1978. – 48. – P. 135–147.
65. Acoustic emission analysis of SUS 304 from fatigue crack under cyclic loading / T. Nagata, Y. Sakakibara, Y. Mori, T. Kishi // Proc. of the 4th Intern. Acoustic emission symposium / Japanese Society for Non Destructive Evaluation. – Tokyo, 1978. – P. 3-45–3-59.
66. Acoustic emission analysis for evaluation of critical faults in welded structures of an austenitic nuclear pressure vessel steel / T. Fiuscher, K. Seifert, H. D. Kunze, K. Wolitz // Proc. of the 4th Intern. Acoustic emission symposium / Japanese Society for Non Destructive Evaluation. – Tokyo, 1978. – P. 4-22–4-32.
67. Jolly W. D. Investigation of flaw and thermal shock in heavy section steel structures with acoustic emission // Proc. of the 4th Intern. Acoustic emission symposium / Japanese Society for Non Destructive Evaluation. – Tokyo, 1978. – P. 4-46–4-53.
68. Rao G. V., Gopal R. Flaw growth characterization studies of irradiated pressure vessel steel by acoustic monitoring technique // Transactions of the American Nuclear Society. – 1980. – 34. – P. 188–189.
69. Iwasaki H. Acoustic emission and fracture patterns of SUS–304 and A533B materials // Proc. of the 5th Intern. Acoustic emission symposium / Japanese Society for Non Destructive Evaluation. – Tokyo, 1980. – P. 209–220.
70. Acoustic emission characteristics of type 304 stainless steel during fatigue crack propagation / Y. Mori, Y. Sahakibara, T. Nagata et al. // Proc. of the 5th Intern. Acoustic emission symposium / Japanese Society for Non Destructive Evaluation. – Tokyo, 1980. – P. 465–474.
71. Баранов В. М., Молодцов К. И. Акустико-эмиссионные приборы ядерной энергетики. – М.: Атомиздат, 1980. – 142 с.
72. Акустическая эмиссия и ее применение для неразрушающего контроля в ядерной энергетике / В. И. Артюхов, К. Б. Вакар, В. И. Макаров и др. // Под ред. К. Б. Вакара. – М.: Атомиздат. – 1980. – 216 с.
 
First acoustic-emission (AE) measuring systems of production type were developed and correlations between parameters of AE signals and fracture propagation indices were established in the second half of the XXth century. This is exactly what aroused the interest of developers of nuclear power engineering technologies and operators in this new method, which later on will become an effective addition to the currently available technologies of nondestructive testing (NDT) for detection and monitoring of defects in nuclear reactor bodies. As extremely high requirements of quality and integrity are made of such facilities, considerable efforts were aimed at development of AE method and its introduction into industry already at the end of 1970ties. Practical implementation of the methods and procedures of AE monitoring and diagnostics of the condition of NPP reactor bodies confirmed the high effectiveness of the method, although at the beginning of their introduction into industry different opinions were expressed on this subject.
 
Keywords: acoustic emission, fracture propagation indices, nuclear power engineering technologies
 
Надійшла редакції 10.07.2014
Піписано до друку 5.11.2014